Guest Editorial
by Jonathan Timberlake
| Brachystegia spiciformis in coastal miombo woodland, Inhambane, Mozambique. (Photo: John Burrows) |
Meg Coates Palgrave, who died in March 2024, had a significant influence on southern African botany, primarily through her involvement with ‒ and later revision of ‒ the seminal book "Trees of Southern Africa". She and her husband Paul made a major contribution to the first edition, initially written by brother-in-law Keith. Then in the 1990s, in conjunction with local botanists such as Bob Drummond and Braam van Wyk, she undertook the mammoth task of revising it (published 2002) to include new species, better distributions and keys. This comprehensive book is often regarded as the bible for those of us needing to identity the great range of woody plants across the region, especially as it includes ALL species, not just those considered common, widespread or more noteworthy. For example, I cut my southern Africa botanical teeth in Botswana in 1978 with the first edition of TSA, my copy now with many notes, dog-eared and a much patched-up spine. It is perhaps the most widely used of our botanical books, certainly north of the Limpopo.
Always willing to join up with other botanists, Meg took any opportunity to arrange trips and get out into the field to identify plants and learn something new. These could be visiting botanists - such as John Burrows and team in Mozambique, Susan Carter (Kew) in the Eastern Highlands looking at Aloes, or Braam van Wyk in South Africa - or on the numerous Tree Society of Zimbabwe outings in which she participated. I remember Meg's enthusiasm, when working at a lodge at Bumi Hills on the shores of Lake Kariba in 1989, to join me and Nozipo Nobanda during the communal lands' vegetation survey, taking a day off to get out into the scrub and dry forests to discuss vegetation and characteristic species and what was behind the patterns found.
| Miombo woodland on shallow soils with granite dwala, Mutinondo Wilderness Area, N Zambia (photo: Jonathan Timberlake) |
Meg gave numerous talks or short courses for farmers and members of the interested public on tree identification, initially in Zimbabwe but later in Zambia and South Africa, during which her catchphrase "all trees have a label; you just need to know what it is" became well-known. These were generally done in conjunction with other local botanists such as Kim Damstra, Cathy Sharp and Lari Merritt. A major 'trademark' was the use of simple local keys that she and others developed based on leaf characters, keys that would work in a particular area and with non-flowering material, which - let’s face it - is normally the situation. In those keys she frequently used regular photocopies of leaves, which surprisingly often retained the necessary identification features. From these courses came the publication of her very useful book "Key to the Trees of Zimbabwe" in 1996. Then, in later years, Meg teamed up with mycologist Cathy Sharp in Zambia and Zimbabwe to give short field courses focussed not just on tree identification but also on the linkages between miombo species and ectomycorrhizal fungi. Such courses, given to a wide range of people, made botany not only more accessible but also more interesting. Indeed, for many they remain memorable occasions.
After the mammoth revision of TSA, Meg developed an interest in more specific botanical issues, particularly those pertaining to miombo – the woodland vegetation type characterised by trees in the genera Brachystegia, Julbernardia and Isoberlinia that extends over 2.5 million sq. km. of south-central Africa. She became interested in how the various species reproduced, picking up on Graham Piearce's observation that for many Caesalpinioid trees (which are often dominant in miombo) this is by root suckers and coppice rather than seed. Then she became interested in possible Brachystegia hybrids and distributions but Meg wasn't generally willing to accept hybrids and preferred to put things into boxes.
| View over drier miombo woodland in the Lugenda area, Niassa Game Reserve, N Mozambique (photo: Jonathan Timberlake) |
However, Brachystegia is a very varied genus ‒ just look at the problems that Arthur Hoyle in Oxford had, naming many herbarium specimens as hybrids or even backcrosses. There is a great variation within many of them - such as Brachystegia spiciformis with its enormous African range from Kenya to northern South Africa, and from the Angolan coast to that of Mozambique - while other species remain much more limited in their phenotype and distribution. And now there is evidence of introgression between some groups, with possible interconnections through limited gene flow between taxa. This makes simple explanations even harder. One conclusion is that diversity in Brachystegia is sometimes better explained by geography and how far apart the populations are, rather than by simple taxonomy. So perhaps it is just not possible to always put individual specimens into separate clear-cut taxa, something that Meg would not always agree with.
The last time I saw her was in the Kew Herbarium in early 2020 while she was on a family trip to UK. She wanted to see if some Brachystegias from Matabeleland in western Zimbabwe were actually Brachystegia utilis and not – as I and some others still suspect – a hybrid of B. spiciformis and B. microphylla/glaucescens. This uncertainty led to her trying to get some genetic sequencing done somewhere to clarify the issue. In this she had much help from Cathy Sharp and Judy Ross, who collected many specimens from across Zimbabwe as source material. However, such analyses proved too difficult to arrange without being part of a wider study, although Cathy tells me that there is still a plan to try and get the collected specimens analysed genetically in a university department somewhere, sometime.
Meg's main legacy will
always be her contributions to Trees of Southern Africa, a book which is
scientifically-based yet that has encouraged what are now generations of
botanists across the region to identify trees. What was previously a subject
more the province of specialists became that much more accessible. She will
also be remembered by many for the numerous talks and courses she gave on tree
identification – to farmers, naturalist groups, or just interested members of
the public – enabling them to develop an increased appreciation of our natural
world, along with the will and means to defend it.
No comments:
Post a Comment